Secret Santa Alternatives for Work: 9 Ideas Your Team Will Actually Enjoy

Two personalised charm phone cases boxed up as gifts

Office Christmas

Nobody needs another novelty mug.

By The Charmé Edit workshop teamUpdated 17 November 20265 min read

The short answer

Good Secret Santa alternatives for work include a white elephant swap, a swap with one simple rule, a book swap, a team donation to charity, thank-you notes instead of gifts, or swapping presents for a shared activity. Our favourite mixes the last two: a make-and-swap workshop. Everyone draws a name, designs a charm photo frame or patch tote with that colleague in mind, then hands it over at the end.

Two personalised charm phone cases boxed up as gifts
Gifts that someone actually made, boxed and ready to swap.

Secret Santa tends to go one of two ways. Either someone puts real thought into it and gets a tin of biscuits back, or half the office panic-buys on the way in on the last morning. If your team is ready for something different this year, here are nine alternatives, with the honest pros and cons of each, and a step-by-step for the one we know best.

What can you do instead of Secret Santa?

01A white elephant swap

Everyone brings one wrapped gift. In turn, people either open a new parcel or steal one that's already been opened. It's loud and a bit competitive, and it suits teams who enjoy some chaos. Agree a spending limit first so nobody feels caught out.

02A swap with one rule

Keep the names, add a constraint: something that starts with the first letter of their name, something from a charity shop, or something they'd use at their desk. The rule does the thinking for people who hate shopping.

03A book swap

Each person wraps a book they loved this year with a note about why. Everyone goes home with a recommendation from a colleague, which is often a better conversation starter than the gift itself.

04Secret Santa for charity

Pool what you'd have spent and give it to a cause the team chooses together. Sign one big card so it still feels like a moment.

05A homemade food swap

Everyone brings something they've baked or made. Label every tin with its ingredients so colleagues with allergies can join in safely.

06Thank-you notes instead of gifts

Draw names as usual, but write the person a proper note about something they did this year. It costs nothing, and people tend to keep them.

07A skills swap

Everyone runs a ten-minute session on something they're good at, from sourdough to spreadsheets. Good for curious teams.

08An experience instead of presents

Drop the gifts and put the money towards doing something together: a long lunch, a quiz or a workshop.

09A make-and-swap workshop

The gift exchange and the team activity in one. Everyone makes a present for the person they drew, with materials and help on hand, and the swap happens at the end. Here's how it works.

How does a make-and-swap workshop work?

We run it as a private charm workshop, either at your office or at our space in Canary Wharf. It needs a little prep, but nothing anyone would call admin.

  1. Draw names before the day. Do it the usual way, by hat or by app.
  2. Collect a few clues. A favourite colour, a hobby, their initials, a place they love. Three clues is plenty.
  3. Design for your person. On the day, everyone chooses charms, shells and pearls with their colleague in mind and sets them into a 4 × 6 inch photo frame, with our help.
  4. Wrap and swap. Finish with the exchange, and let people guess who made theirs.

From the workshop table

Choose photo frames, not phone cases, for a swap. A case has to match the recipient's phone model, and asking for it gives the game away. A frame suits anyone, and you can slip a team photo in before you wrap it.

Charm photo frames decorated with shells, pearls and flowers
Frames work for any recipient.
Personalised tote bags with initials and patches laid out at a London workshop
Totes suit bigger teams.

Bigger team? Try a tote swap

For larger groups, our tote bag workshop runs for 2 to 30 people. The swap works the same way: spell out your person's initials in letter patches, add two or three patches that suit them, and our team heat-presses the design onto an organic cotton tote. There are Christmas patches too, from Santa to gingerbread. See our Christmas tote bag workshop.

Which idea suits your team?

Idea Effort to organise Best for
White elephant swap Low Lively teams who like a game
One-rule swap Low Teams who want to keep Secret Santa but make it easier
Book swap Low Readers, and quieter teams
Charity donation Low Teams who'd rather give than receive
Thank-you notes Very low Any team, including remote ones
Make-and-swap workshop Medium: book a date and draw names Teams who want a Christmas social and a gift exchange in one afternoon

If you'd like us to host

How a private charm workshop with us works:

Where
Our workshop space in Canary Wharf (up to 12 guests), or your home, office or venue in London, with a travel fee based on distance
What you make
A personalised charm phone case or a 4 × 6 inch charm photo frame. Guests can choose on the day
How long
About an hour of making. Most private sessions run one to two hours
Included
A case or frame for each guest, 100+ curated charms, shells and pearls, all tools, setup, hosting, light snacks and hot drinks
Skill needed
None. We demo first, then help at every step
To enquire
Send your date, guest numbers, location and each guest's phone model

Enquire about a private workshopWhat happens on the day

“It was so fun and cutesy, and honestly the most creative corporate activity.”

Sophie H, private corporate workshop

Questions we hear a lot

Frequently asked questions

What is a good alternative to Secret Santa at work?

A white elephant swap, a book swap, a charity donation, thank-you notes or a make-and-swap workshop where everyone makes the gift for the colleague they drew.

How do you do Secret Santa without buying gifts?

Write each other thank-you notes, run a skills swap, bake for each other, or put the money towards a shared team activity.

What is a white elephant gift exchange?

Everyone brings one wrapped gift. In turn, each person opens a new gift or steals one that's already been opened.

Can you run a make-and-swap workshop at our office?

Yes. We bring the charm workshop to offices across London, or you can host up to 12 people at our Canary Wharf space. For bigger teams, our tote bag workshop runs for 2 to 30 people.

Do we need everyone's phone model?

Not for a swap. We recommend photo frames, which suit any recipient. Phone cases need the owner's phone model.

How do I book?

For a charm workshop, send an enquiry through our private events page or email support@thecharmeedit.com with your date, guest numbers, location and each guest's phone model, and we'll send a tailored quote. For the tote bag workshop, book a place on our ClassBento listing or enquire about a private group.

Finished charm phone case with gold and red charms on a gold tray

Make this year's swap the one people remember

Plan a make-and-swap workshop